Dr. Monte S. Finkelstein
Holocaust Summer Study Institute-2000 - Handout
Italy's Attempt to Prevent Jewish Extermination
Return to the Lecture

 

Italy: The Prevention of Jewish Extermination

 This outline will provide a brief framework of my lecture so that following it will not be an impossible task to keep up with me and take notes.

 Background 70 AD to 1922
 Fascism
 The War Years 1940 to 1943
 July 1943 to April 1945

 

 

 

 

A. BACKGROUND -70 A.D. to 1922

1. Except for specific instances Jews living in Italy basically lived unmolested

2. Rome the oldest Jewish community in Europe; by 100 A.D. about a dozen synagogues in Rome and 100, 000 Jews in Rome; other communities in north and central Italy

3. In 1400's Italy was considered one of the best areas in terms of treatment of Jews; about 1500 Jewish population in Italy peaked at 120,000

4. 16th century religious Reformation brought distinctive clothing for and restrictions on Jews

5. First "official" ghetto established in Rome in 1555

6. Jews participated in drive to unify Italy (Risorgimento); new Italian state outlawed ghettos

7. After unification (1870) Jews assimilated well into Italian society; occupied high government positions, served in the army, helped to fight in World War I; mixed freely in every aspect of Italian society

8. Why did Italy not have the same level of anti-Semitism as other countries?

a. demography

b. assimilation

c. economics

d. regionalism and humanism

Top of the Page

 

 

 

 

B. FASCISM

1. Mussolini's rise did not disturb Italian Jews to a great degree; saw him as the savior of Italy for several reasons

2. Jews joined the Fascist ranks and financially supported the movement; opposed it for political reasons

3. Mussolini spent life vacillating on the issues of anti-Semitism and Italian Jews; sometimes defended them; other times acted like an anti-Semite

4. Until 1935, signs of anti-Semitism under Fascism negligible; Ethiopian War changed everything; Mussolini and Hitler drew closer; Mussolini wanted to keep up with Hitler and be taken seriously and believed that anti-Semitism would be one way to do this.

5. On his own, Mussolini decided to initiate campaign of anti-Semitism in Italy

a. July 1938- "The Defense of the Race" manifesto issued-Controversial

b. November 1938- Racial laws against Jews first issued; later measures followed. Removed citizenship, excluded them armed forces, certain business, forbid intermarriage, etc..

c. laws not welcomed or supported by Italian people; saw them as Mussolini's attempt to ingratiate himself with Hitler; many Italian bureaucrats, administrators, high level government officials, and ordinary ignored the laws and sought to circumvent them.

d. Jews reacted in various ways: shock, disbelief, acceptance and protest
(Ovazza)

Top of the Page

 

 

 

 

 

 

C. THE WAR YEARS 1940-1943

1. Once war began, Jews in Italy subject to forced labor, arrest, internment camps

2. anti-Semitic violence occurred but Italian situation never reached that of other nations

3. Germans disgusted with Italian leniency; constantly demanded that Italians take harsher measures; Italians ignored Germans; no Italian Jew or Jewish person living
under Italian jurisdiction given over the Germans

4. Italian protection extended to Italian and non-Italian Jews living in areas under their military occupation

a. France (Lospinoso)

b. Yugoslavia

c. Greece (Castrucci)

5. Why did Italians protect Jews in other nations?

a. anti-German sentiment

b. no belief in anti-Semitism

c. demonstration of Italian power

Top of the Page

 

 

 

 

 

D. JULY 1943-APRIL 1945

1. Mussolini overthrown in July 1945, new anti-Fascist government joined with Allies; brought German invasion of Italy

2. Italian protection of Jews in other lands quickly ended; Germans brought Holocaust machinery to Italy; aided by high ranking Fascists who were among the most fanatic of Mussolini's followers

3. General population and lower officials continue to aid Jews in face of severe punishment

4. Germans passed restrictive measures against Jews and conducted roundups in several Italian cities

a. Rome- October 1943- Jews rounded up and sent to Auschwitz- Why no strong reaction by the Pope?

b. Jews in cities of northern and central Italy suffered same fate; many Jews escaped deportation and death because Italians from all walks of life continued to aid them

c. At least 2000-3000 Jews joined Italian resistance

5. April 1945- Allies liberate Italy; Holocaust was over; 80-85 percent of Italian Jews had survived. WHY?

a. shorter danger period

b. small number of Jews

c. assimilation

d. Italian refusal to obey laws

e. individual action and friendly population

6. Why did Italians protect Jews?

a. resentment of Germans, Fascists, and war

b. historical lack of anti-Semitism

c. economics and assimilation

d. national and individual character

Top of the Page

Return to the Lecture

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Return to the Lecture

Sources

 Nora Levin, The Holocaust: The Destruction of European Jewry, 1933-1945 (New York, 1968)

Lucy Dawidowicz, The War Against the Jews 1933-1945 (New York, 1975)

Works on Italy

Alexander Stille, Benevolence and Betrayal: Five Italian Families Under Fascism (New York, 1991)

Meir Michaelis, Mussolini and the Jews: German-Italian Relations and the Jewish Question in Italy, 1922-1945 (London, 1978)

Ivo Herzer, editor, The Italian Refuge: Rescue of Jews During the Holocaust (Washington, D.C., 1989)

Susan Zuccotti, The Italians and the Holocaust: Persecution, Rescue, Survival (New York, 1987)

Maria de Blasio Wilhelm, The Other Italy: The Italian Resistance in World War II (New York, 1988)

There are other works in Italian for which I can provide citations.

Return to the Lecture